Spoiler Warning!If you watch The Dark Knight only with an eye for adventure in the form of explosions and mayhem, it’s easy to miss the Joker’s extremely intimate nature. One of the most intriguing things about this character is that he will tell you he is doing one thing while actually doing another. Consider the fact that he tells Harvey Dent he isn’t a planner or a “schemer,” even while pulling off extremely meticulous plans, and you'll see you can't take everything he says at face value.
The behavior he exhibits that we think of as antisocial is actually an indication of his extreme need for interaction and intimacy. If the Joker didn’t want to interact with people, he wouldn’t force them into his games, and he probably wouldn’t stand quite so close or touch them quite so much.
These expressions of intimacy take three forms: his extreme presence, his sensual nature and the things he reveals about himself. As frightening as some of these manifestations are, they provide his female viewers with plenty of fodder for fantasy.
A Man of PresenceOne of the most common complaints you will ever hear from a woman regarding a man she actually likes is that she can’t seem to get his attention. He doesn’t listen to her. He doesn’t look at her that special way anymore. All he does is sit in front of the television or play video games.
Television and video games are passive activities. They are non-interactive, and by interactive I mean face-to-face, real human interaction. People often use entertainment to "disappear" for a while. Not looking at people and not listening or reacting to what they say are also strategies for disappearing. When we disappear, we become non-entities. We have no presence.
What is presence? It is the state of being aware of, influenced by, and able to influence people and events around you. In order to have presence, you must give your audience – whether one or many – your full attention. You must react to what they do and say and you must respond. Though listening is a large part of gauging the information your audience is giving you, presence is actually conveyed with the eyes.
When discussing a man with presence, a woman will often say she fell in love with him because of the way he looked at her. We crave each other’s undivided attention. Because many people are unwilling to give another that undivided attention, or because they simply don’t know how or are afraid to, the man who can do that is a force to be reckoned with.
If the Joker has a superpower, that ability to focus and make people feel his presence is it.
From the armed bank employee to the meeting of mobsters to Gambol to Brian the fake Batman to Bruce Wayne’s party guests, the Joker gives his audience his full attention. He listens and responds to them. He looks them in the eye. He mesmerizes them with stories, voice and touch.
More than anyone in the film, the viewer gets the feeling that the Joker is 100-percent there. And being there, being
present, is sexy.
The interesting thing about the Joker is that he isn’t immune himself to craving the presence of others. He demands participation. He wants his audience’s full attention in return for his. “Look at me,” he commands on several occasions when his victims attempt to “disappear” on him, becoming angry if that command isn’t followed immediately.
Joker’s Hands-on ApproachJust because we have been trained to think of sensuality as a term that must be discussed only in terms of sweet romantic trysts doesn’t mean it belongs there. Sensuality is simply the use and enjoyment of the five senses. When you take off your shoes and squish your toes in the carpet, you are being sensual. When you enjoy that everything-on chilidog or marvel how your friend’s car handles the road, you are being sensual. Painters often become painters because they like the way it feels to put paint on canvas. Children enjoy Play-Doh because of the way it feels in their hands. All of these activities are sensual, even if they aren’t overtly sexual.
The Joker employs an in-your-face sensuality, which is part of what makes him so very frightening. He both gives and receives sensual stimulation as a matter of course, beginning with the basics of sight and sound. His appearance, for starters, is as fascinating and alluring as it is terrifying. His makeup not only calls to mind clowns, which for many people are nightmarish apparitions, it calls to mind pain and death in the visage of a trauma victim with sunken or blackened eyes and bloody mouth. It accentuates the scarring that has robbed his face of its original beauty and turned him into something that could be absolutely repellant.
Could be, but isn't.
His insistence on invading personal space and physically touching his victims far more than is necessary, the constant threat of his blade, the sound of his voice as he tells his scar stories, the lip-licking habit that both frightens and entices – even the sheer pleasure he gets from hanging out of the window of a moving car – all give evidence of that feral sensuality and lend him an animalistic appeal. Even the fact that he sweats off his war paint and avoids washing his hair only adds to his visceral nature.
The Joker is a master of both giving and receiving the ultimate in physical sensation – pain. He rides the line admirably between torture-room sadist and extreme masochist. Only a master pain-slut can take the blows he takes from Batman quite so gleefully.
He even admits his enjoyment of intimacy during his conversation with the police officer in the interrogation room. “You wanna know…why…I use a knife?” he asks. “Guns are too quick. You can’t savor all the…
little…emotions. You…you see…in their… last moments…people show ya who they really are. So, in a way…I knew your friends better than you ever did.”
Tears of a ClownYes, I went there. And you are too.
One of the most common ways of establishing intimacy with another person is to reveal things about yourself. The Joker tells only two stories about his scars in The Dark Knight, but those are two of the most dramatic and memorable moments of a high-drama film. Forget the literal truth of the stories for a moment. You can tell a jury to disregard testimony all you want, but they will not be able to erase the emotions created by what they’ve heard. The same goes for the Joker’s audience.
The first story is of a deranged father who killed the boy Joker’s mother and maliciously scarred his face. The second tells of a man so desperate to cheer up his wife that he mutilates himself, only to have her leave him in the end because she doesn’t like the way he looks. I get the sense that both stories are true in essence – an abusive father perhaps killing his mother, and a wife’s rejection of him because of what he was becoming – even if they don’t shed much light on the thing he pretends to explain.
He isn’t actually talking about his facial scars. He’s talking about his emotional scars. The hurt and anger he expresses in the telling of the stories all serve to not only mesmerize his victim, but to humanize him for a moment, and that effect brings the audience further into his snare.
He seduces with lies and half-truths. He also seduces by recognizing the deep-seated issues of others. One of the best ways to recognize another person’s issues is to share them. Therefore, the fact that he pegs Harvey Dent as a man concerned with fairness and Jim Gordon as a man struggling with isolation suggests that the Joker is also concerned about these things. He has intimate knowledge of how these emotions work on people and is therefore able to use them against others.
In fact, Batman himself uses the same trick on the Joker moments after the ferries fail to blow, when he says, “You’re alone.” And we already know Bruce Wayne has been burdened by solitude for a very long time.
Even if a potential seduction victim sitting in the audience fails to recognize these clues to the Joker’s psyche on a conscious level, she will still be affected by them. The Joker’s extreme presence, highly sensual nature and emotional revelations combine to help him establish intimacy with her so that, by the end of the film, she is suitably primed to write fanfiction, alter official images and build fan sites in his honor.
This is No. 5 in my article series
Sex and the Joker: Batman's Nemesis as Underground Sex Symbol. Read the
previous post in the series. Read the
next post.